The other question I had was, since I'm in a snowy biome (although I'm underground), does that limit the trees I can plant? How did German unification affect existing sentences for criminal convicts? I am playing on the Windows 10 Edition. Adding an extra block of space on every side should be enough. Thanks for the tip I'll try Jack O Lanterns as I'm not yet ready for the nether. site design / logo © 2020 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under cc by-sa.

#1 Feb 6, 2011.

I have a 3 level underground farm, i'll post picks of it later on tonight, its about 7x24 and 4 tall for the first 2 levels and the 3rd level is my cocoa tree semi auto farm the first 2 levels are copies of one another in layout, The layout is as follows. Btw one of the other replies says "If there are torches on the walls, remove them". They also have a minimum horizontal requirement as well. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts.

How to refuse to work when on vacation while keeping relationships as best as possible? :D. The Oak trees aren't growing, though... makes me think it still registers as a snowy biome, even though I'm underground. How can I handle a PC wanting to be a "twist" villain? Note that the requirements are different for different types of trees, so that advice is based on Oak. Arqade is a question and answer site for passionate videogamers on all platforms. The spawn point was in a snowy biome, so that's all the trees I had to work with.

How to de-mob a deep/large underground chasm in Minecraft? Overlord312. Birch should work in the same setup though. rev 2020.11.10.37982, Sorry, we no longer support Internet Explorer, The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Arqade works best with JavaScript enabled, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site, Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, Learn more about hiring developers or posting ads with us. The problem is the trees in the middle grew almost right away, but the trees on the edges refuse to grow. Would it be possible to provide a screenshot of your situation?

Anyway, I put the trees with 2 blocks in between (as I was reading guides on how the trees are to grow). P.S. How to Make a Tree Farm. I was really hoping to farm Oak trees as well. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts.

The issue I have with the branches is that they … Hello Minecraft Reddit! When to carry on with a buggy game state versus terminate the process. Also, a torch directly next to the sapling will provide sufficient light.

The spawn point was in a snowy biome, so that's all the trees I had to work with. https://minecraft.gamepedia.com/Sapling#Growing_trees, https://minecraft.gamepedia.com/Tree#Spruce_tree.

The whole sapling, ring of air, ring of torches will allow trees to grow OUTSIDE at NIGHT. (I'm testing it now.) Zeal. No horizontal clearance is needed at the base of the tree and 1 level above (a sapling planted in a hole 2 blocks deep can still grow). However, at 8 blocks high branches do grow. Thanks! If you use bonemeal and nothing happens, then you don't have enough space. Stack Exchange network consists of 176 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers.

Would capping at 6 or 7 be more recommended, then, even if it produces less saplings? I should point out that sometimes if a tree can be nothing but big (because of tree farms or terrain) it takes more than one bonemeal to make it grow.

7 wide by 24 long grid. Overlord312. LEDs only light up when my fingers are near arbitrary parts of the circuit. Was there a way to directly print out a deck of punch cards without involving a computer? I've used like, 10 bonemeals on it and it isn't working. This method will work underground as well, so keep that in mind! Were a large number of votes from suspiciously old Pennsylvanians received in the 2020 US presidential election? @JonathanDrain I personally like to keep the height low enough so big trees. How can I turn this into a perfect cylinder. Here's a step by step guide for how my underground tree farm that won't grow trees, Use torches to create 9 5x5 squares. (Counting the torches.)

1×1 spruce trees require a 5×5 column of unobstructed space at least 7 blocks above the sapling to grow (8 blocks including the sapling itself). So I duplicated the setup in a super flat test world then applied roughly 5 stacks of bonemeal to the CENTER tree and still nothing. If you enjoy a quick and efficient tree farm, this is the method for you. I got it to work now.

Why could Hagrid cast spells non-verbally? Ran into an issue and went to my default mindset of "someone on Reddit will have an answer!". How do scientists know the min limit of temperature is -273 degree celsius?

Trees need 7 blocks above them to grow, depending on sapling type. Trees can only grow if they have enough room to do so. It was indeed too close to the wall, lol. Does Google collect and store data about activity done in Incognito mode?

Make sure you're using regular dirt, not coarse dirt (I know, I know, but I've seen it 100 times). – Robotnik ♦ Oct 11 '12 at 4:31. add a comment | Not the answer you're looking for? How can I grow trees underground? The whole sapling, ring of air, ring of torches will allow trees to grow OUTSIDE at NIGHT. Yet after AFKing ALL NIGHT while I slept my underground tree farm had yet to a single tree. Make sure no torch is directly adjacent to your sapling.

Anyway, question I had is I was trying to make an underground spruce tree farm. Image to the farm: https://imgur.com/a/kp7ooTm. Trying to figure out why. What is the exact maximum height oak trees can grow? …

Possible Duplicate: What is the reasoning behind nighttime restrictions during pandemic? If you're building an indoor tree-farm and worried about tree height, why not build a balcony (into the wall, so as not to obstruct growing height) so you can walk straight onto the top of the tree from there? Hollow out more space. View User Profile View Posts Send Message Carpenter; Join Date: 1/27/2011 Posts: 52 Member … Dig out a 13x13x13 cube. If there are torches on the walls, remove them. Optimal Underground Tree Farm Height?

(Counting the torches.). It's a normal sapling on 5 deep dirt. Also using a fullblock light source like glowstone or jack o lanterns works too. Anyway, I put the trees with 2 blocks in between (as I was reading guides on how the trees are to grow). If you're building an indoor tree-farm and worried about tree height, why not build a balcony (into the wall, so as not to obstruct growing height) so you can walk straight onto the top of the tree from there? Browse other questions tagged minecraft-java-edition or ask your own question. The site may not work properly if you don't, If you do not update your browser, we suggest you visit, Press J to jump to the feed.

What prevents chess engines from being undetectable? Unfortunately, your question is quite vague - are you sure the tree has enough room? (Doing it underground because everywhere is mountains and there's no flat areas to really farm...). I've never had any problem growing trees underground, true last time was a few versions ago but I really wouldn't expect that to have changed. What seems to be wrong with my automated Lettuce farm? Rebuilding when current house has a mortgage. I was confused at first by the whole 5x5 thing, but I get it now. I have had trees require significantly more than 10 bonemeal to grow if the growth area is highly constrained. Getting 30 oaks planted is just as good anyway. Using spreadplayers to tp them to armorstand in unloaded chunk. Consult the wiki for the exact size required. In the center of each square plant a sapling. If I have a single diamond worth more than 300 gp, does Revivify consume the whole diamond? I got fired on my last day; is that possible? New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, Press J to jump to the feed. #1 Nov 30, 2011. Cookies help us deliver our Services. Here's a step by step guide for how my underground tree farm that won't grow trees. What is English counterpart to Japanese phrase, “往生際が悪い” – behave disgracefully toward the end of life? What is the problem with my setup? Looks like you're using new Reddit on an old browser.

Minecraft Forum; Minecraft: Java Edition; Survival Mode; How tall does an underground tree farm have to be? Did computers come with circuit diagrams? Do the trees need to be planted on grass instead of dirt? (I used oak cause that what I had.

You're correct, of course; I meant to remove the torches temporarily as a test rather than to leave the chamber dark :). Sounds like they just need more space then, probably height. Ok, so I'm trying to plant this tree underground and it's surrounded by torches and directly under a 4x4 sky light.

Can trees grow without sunlight? Oak saplings can grow in a 1x1x5 meter area with dirt under them, but is the minimal amount of area. Best type of trees to harvest (if you don't care about wood color) is the 2x2 spruces.

It only takes a minute to sign up. It's worth adding even more height, in my opinion, so you can get huge type trees. (I used oak cause that what I had. Birch trees should grow as long as they have light and enough room, and it doesn't take anywhere near as many torches as you have. View User Profile View Posts Send Message Carpenter; Join Date: 6/27/2011 Posts: 50 Member Details; The wiki says 8 blocks high. The problem is the trees in the middle grew almost right away, but the trees on the edges refuse to grow.

If you do not nearly have enough, don't worry!

Use torches to create 9 5x5 squares. Hello, CtK, and welcome to Arqade! Just recently got back into the game after having not played since 2011 (and I forgot how addicting this game was). [duplicate], Creating new Help Center documents for Review queues: Project overview, Feature Preview: New Review Suspensions Mod UX, Screenshot of the Week Contest #25 [Submissions closed, vote now! Zeal. By using our site, you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Cookie Policy, Privacy Policy, and our Terms of Service. You will need 61 total oak saplings for this tree farm.

But you would have to dig such a high ceiling to do them underground it's not worth it. Search Search all Forums Search this Forum Search this Thread Tools Jump to Forum How tall does an underground tree farm have to be?

], Recommendations on lighting up a big uneven surface. Anyway, question I had is I was trying to make an underground spruce tree farm. Thanks! In the center of each square plant a sapling.

China using gunpowder to take over Europe in the 1200s? By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. My guess is they are too close to the wall. I would change this advice to "dig a hole in the wall and set the torches 1 block further back".